Supreme Court lets New Hampshire shut out student IDs 12 days before the midterms
An unsigned order revives a ban on officials weighing student IDs. Justice Jackson dissented alone; students without a license face new hurdles.
The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday, Oct. 22, let New Hampshire's secretary of state bar election officials from treating student IDs as proof of identity in the Nov. 3 midterms. The unsigned order in Scanlan v. Coalition for Open Democracy (No. 26A512) pauses a federal judge's ruling that kept student IDs in play. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the only justice shown dissenting.
The order hits college students and other young voters hardest, especially those without a driver's license or passport.
How we got here
New Hampshire's Republican-backed HB 323, signed by Gov. Kelly Ayotte on April 3, struck student IDs from the list of photo IDs voters can show to get a ballot. Secretary of State David Scanlan (R) then directed officials not to consider student IDs at all, even under the law's "safety valve," which lets officials weigh other evidence when a voter lacks a listed ID.
The Coalition for Open Democracy sued. On Oct. 2, U.S. District Judge Joseph Laplante left the law in place but blocked Scanlan's directive "to the extent it prohibits or discourages election officials from considering student IDs." He wrote that "the State has offered no independent justification for that broader prohibition." The 1st Circuit left that ruling standing last week.
What the order says
Citing the Purcell principle, the Court wrote that "lower federal courts should ordinarily not alter the election rules on the eve of an election," and that "the District Court did not point to anything that would justify deviating from that principle."
Jackson wrote that Laplante was "correcting a publicized misstatement about what New Hampshire's election rules require," and that such an injunction "does not contribute to public confusion, it prevents that very problem."
Scanlan and the state won. Young voters lost. The stay lasts while the state's appeal proceeds at the 1st Circuit and through any Supreme Court petition, covering this election. We condemn an order that leaves eligible students guessing about what gets them a ballot 12 days before Election Day.
What you can do
HB 323 accepts a driver's license or state nondriver ID from any state, a U.S. armed services ID, or a U.S. passport or passcard. If you lack one, call your town or city clerk now and ask what else your polling place will accept, then check your registration before Nov. 3. Read our earlier coverage of the state's request.
Sources
- Scanlan v. Coalition for Open Democracy, No. 26A512, order and dissent — Supreme Court of the United States
- Docket No. 26A512 — Supreme Court of the United States
- Supreme Court allows New Hampshire to restrict use of student IDs in voting — SCOTUSblog
- Supreme Court lets New Hampshire fully ban student IDs for voting ahead of midterms — Democracy Docket
- Judge says NH secretary of state went too far on student IDs for voting — New Hampshire Public Radio
- Federal appeals court won't fully block student IDs for voting in New Hampshire — Democracy Docket
- HB 323 (2026) bill text — NH Liberty Alliance bill tracker
Comments ()