Republicans ask Supreme Court to shut out student IDs two weeks before Election Day

Court records show about 7,700 young NH voters lack other ID.

Republicans ask Supreme Court to shut out student IDs two weeks before Election Day
Stock photo. Photo by Cloris Ying on Unsplash

New Hampshire's top election official has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to stop poll workers from even looking at a college student's ID on Nov. 3. Two federal courts have already told him no. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson ordered the voters' side to answer by 11 a.m. Eastern today, according to the Supreme Court docket, and a decision could come any day after that.

The case is Scanlan v. Coalition for Open Democracy, No. 26A512. Secretary of State David Scanlan and Attorney General John Formella filed the emergency stay application on Oct. 15. The Republican National Committee filed a brief backing them on Friday, Oct. 16.

How a student ID became contraband

Gov. Kelly Ayotte signed HB 323 in April. It took public and private school student IDs off the list of photo IDs that get you a ballot, the state's own application says. Scanlan then went further. His April directive told local officials they could not consider student IDs at all, including under the law's "safety valve," which lets an official accept other evidence of identity when a voter lacks a listed ID, InDepthNH reported.

The Coalition for Open Democracy, a voter outreach group represented by Free Speech For People, sued in August. On Oct. 2, U.S. District Judge Joseph Laplante left the new law in place but blocked the directive. He found "the State has identified no interest served by the April Directive beyond those already served by HB 323," NHPR reported, and wrote that the directive "likely cannot withstand scrutiny under the First, Fourteenth, and Twenty-Sixth Amendments." The Twenty-Sixth Amendment is the one that guarantees the vote at 18 and bars age discrimination at the ballot box.

His order bars enforcing the directive "to the extent it prohibits or discourages election officials from considering student IDs as evidence of voter identity," and tells Scanlan to issue revised guidance for the general election.

On Oct. 14, a three-judge First Circuit panel (Judges Gelpí, Aframe and Dunlap) refused to pause that order. "The motion is denied, as appellants have failed to demonstrate that stay relief is in order," the one-page order says. Judge Dunlap noted he would have granted the stay.

The state's argument: it's too late to fix our own mistake

New Hampshire's lead argument is timing. Under the Supreme Court's Purcell principle, federal courts are supposed to avoid changing election rules close to an election. "The district court issued its order just 32 days before the general election," the state wrote, adding that retraining local officials is "impracticable just weeks from the election."

The RNC's lawyers at Consovoy McCarthy blamed the voters' group for filing in August. "The 'emergency' is largely one of their own making," the RNC brief says.

Laplante saw it differently back in September, when he declined to block the rule for the primary. "The general election may be on different footing," he wrote then, as quoted in the record the state filed with the Supreme Court.

Who gets turned away

The court record puts a number on it. An expert for the voters' group estimated that about 6.56% of eligible New Hampshire citizens ages 18 to 24, roughly 7,747 people, lack a qualifying ID. The state's DMV had issued no free voter ID cards to anyone under 20 as of April, according to the same record.

New Hampshire has a long history of students voting where they go to school, WCAX reported. "The fact of the matter is, students can use their student IDs to prove that they are who they say they are," state Rep. Russ Muirhead, a Dartmouth politics professor, told the station.

The state Attorney General's office said New Hampshire "has a strong interest in ensuring that its election laws are applied consistently."

What happens next

Justice Jackson handles emergency applications from the First Circuit. She can rule alone or send the application to the full Court, which in practice decides most contested election requests. If the justices grant a stay, local officials would once again be barred from considering student IDs at the polls two weeks before Election Day.

We back the two lower courts on this one. A state that has already removed student IDs from its ID list gains nothing by also forbidding officials from looking at one, and the voters who pay for that rule are young people casting some of their first ballots.

If you're a student voting in New Hampshire, don't wait on the justices. Bring a driver's license or passport if you have one. Liz Tentarelli, president of the League of Women Voters of New Hampshire, advises bringing an out-of-state ID or passport even if it's expired, InDepthNH reported. If you register at the polls on Nov. 3, you'll also need proof of citizenship or an affidavit attesting to it, according to WCAX.

Sources