Supreme Court rejects Trump's appeal to cut UC researchers' DEI-linked grants

The ruling stands that the cuts likely punished researchers for their perceived viewpoints, a First Amendment violation.

Supreme Court rejects Trump's appeal to cut UC researchers' DEI-linked grants
Stock photo. Photo by Adam Bezer on Unsplash

The Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear the Trump administration's appeal in Trump v. Thakur, leaving in place a ruling that the government likely violated the First Amendment when it canceled University of California research grants over their perceived support for diversity, equity and inclusion.

The one-line denial appeared on the Court's Nov. 16 order list. No justice noted a dissent, and the Court gave no explanation.

What the lower courts found

UC researchers led by Neeta Thakur filed a class action in 2025 after federal agencies cut their grants under Trump's January 2025 executive orders on DEI and "gender ideology." U.S. District Judge Rita Lin in San Francisco ordered the grants restored. On May 26, a Ninth Circuit panel of Judges Richard Paez, Morgan Christen and Roopali Desai upheld that order for researchers whose grants were cut over DEI.

The panel agreed with the researchers that the government had "terminated individual grants in existing programs based on the perceived viewpoints of individual speakers." It noted the government "does not dispute" that it cut the grants because of "the recipients' perceived expression of DEI, DEIA, or environmental justice viewpoints."

The remaining fight covers National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities grants, including projects on racial equity in science education and science education for Indigenous youth, Reuters reported. Reuters put the money at about $59 million; CNN reported about $150 million.

Each side

The Justice Department argued that the First Amendment "does not prohibit the government from declining to award competitive grants that fund research projects that promote DEI," CNN reported. Two courts rejected that argument.

"I am obviously delighted that the court denied" the petition, Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of UC Berkeley School of Law and a lawyer for the researchers, told Reuters.

The ruling matters beyond UC. In August 2025, the Supreme Court let the administration go ahead with sweeping NIH grant cuts on procedural grounds, steering those claims toward the specialized Court of Federal Claims. Monday's denial leaves this First Amendment case in an ordinary federal court, which Georgetown law professor Steve Vladeck told CNN can "move much faster and much more coercively to restore funds that were wrongly cut off."

What's next

The case returns to Judge Lin's court. No next hearing date has been reported.

Sources