SEIU asks D.C. Circuit to scrap Trump-era joint employer rule. Franchise and staffing workers' bargaining is at stake.
The 2020 rule says a brand or client company must actually exercise "substantial direct and immediate control" before it has to bargain.
A federal appeals court hears arguments Monday on a question that decides whether fast-food, hotel and warehouse workers hired through franchisees and staffing agencies can bargain with the companies that shape their jobs: when is the brand or client company legally their employer, too?
The Service Employees International Union is asking the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit to throw out the National Labor Relations Board's 2020 joint-employer rule. The case, Service Employees International Union v. NLRB, No. 25-1119, is first on the court's calendar at 9:30 a.m. on Nov. 16 before Judges Henderson, Millett and Rogers, with 15 minutes per side.
What the 2020 rule says
Under federal labor law, a "joint employer" has to bargain with its workers' union and shares liability for labor-law violations with the company that signs the paychecks. The 2020 rule, written during the first Trump administration, sets a high bar. A company counts only if it "possess[es] and exercise[s] such substantial direct and immediate control" over essential terms of employment, which the rule lists as wages, benefits, hours, hiring, firing, discipline, supervision and direction, according to the regulation. A company's "contractually reserved but never exercised authority" over those terms counts only if it backs up evidence of direct control.
In practice, a franchisor or warehouse operator that writes detailed rules into its contracts with a franchisee or staffing agency, but leaves the day-to-day bossing to that local company, generally stays off the hook.
SEIU filed its petition on May 2, 2025, Bloomberg Law reported. Its opening brief argues that the common law treats an "as-yet unexercised right to control" a worker as enough to make a company an employer, and it asks the court to vacate the rule, according to a March 9, 2026 brief filed by the union's opponents that cites those pages of SEIU's brief.
Who's on each side
The NLRB is defending the rule. The International Franchise Association, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the Restaurant Law Center, the American Hotel & Lodging Association and the Coalition for Democratic Workplace filed that March brief, saying they "all agree with the National Labor Relations Board" that SEIU's challenge "fails on the merits." They argue that "SEIU's preferred approach would create chaos in the collective-bargaining process," and warn that franchisors who reserve authority over things like food-safety standards could be treated as employers of franchise workers.
The business groups also argue the D.C. Circuit can't hear the case at all because rule challenges must start in a district court. The board doesn't dispute the appeals court's jurisdiction, their brief notes. SEIU and the NLRB told a D.C. federal judge in a joint motion that "judicial economy" favored letting the appeals court decide that question, Bloomberg Law reported, and SEIU's 2021 lawsuit there is on hold.
A standard that keeps changing
The fight over who counts as a joint employer has swung back and forth for a decade. For example:
- December 2018: In a case involving recycling-plant workers supplied by a staffing agency, the D.C. Circuit held that reserved and indirect control are relevant to joint-employer status, but sent the case back because the board "did not confine its consideration of indirect control consistently with common-law limitations," the Congressional Research Service summarized.
- March 8, 2024: U.S. District Judge J. Campbell Barker in Tyler, Texas, vacated the Biden-era 2023 rule, which would have counted reserved and indirect control, in Chamber of Commerce v. NLRB, No. 6:23-cv-00553 (E.D. Tex.). He wrote that it "would treat virtually every entity that contracts for labor as a joint employer." The NLRB dropped its appeal that July while saying it still believed the rule was lawful, Reuters reported.
- Feb. 27, 2026: The board formally put the 2020 text back in its regulations, calling the step "ministerial." Board Member David Prouty joined but wrote in a footnote that he does not believe the 2020 rule "sets forth the proper standard."
What's at stake for workers
If the 2020 rule stands, fast-food and warehouse workers employed through franchisees and staffing agencies will usually have to bargain only with the smaller local company, even when the brand or client company sets the conditions around them. If SEIU wins vacatur, the business groups argue the board would fall back to deciding joint-employer status case by case.
No decision date is set. The panel could also dismiss the case on jurisdiction without ever deciding whether the rule is lawful. The court streams its arguments live, with links on its calendar page.
Sources
- Oral Argument Calendar, Future Dates, U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
- 29 CFR § 103.40 - Joint employers, Cornell Legal Information Institute
- Withdrawal of 2023 Standard for Determining Joint Employer Status, 91 FR 9707 (Feb. 27, 2026), Federal Register via GovInfo
- Brief for Amici Curiae International Franchise Association et al., SEIU v. NLRB, No. 25-1119 (Mar. 9, 2026), D.C. Circuit filing hosted by the International Franchise Association
- Chamber of Commerce v. NLRB, No. 6:23-cv-00553, Opinion and Order (Mar. 8, 2024), U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas via GovInfo
- Challenge to NLRB Joint Employer Rule Heads to Circuit Court, Bloomberg Law (copy hosted by Constangy)
- US labor board drops bid to revive rule on contract, franchise workers, Reuters (via Yahoo Finance)
- D.C. Circuit Affirms Joint Employer Standard in End-of-Year Decision, Congressional Research Service (via EveryCRSReport)
Comments ()