Judge permanently blocks DOJ from withholding grants to coerce ICE cooperation
A coalition of 23 plaintiffs says the conditions would have forced states to help DHS to keep federal crime-fighting money.
A federal judge in Rhode Island has permanently blocked the Justice Department from conditioning certain police and juvenile justice grants on states' help with immigration enforcement. Chief U.S. District Judge John J. McConnell Jr. ruled Wednesday, Nov. 4, according to the Jersey Vindicator. New Jersey's attorney general's office says the court found the conditions unlawful and barred the government from enforcing them.
The case is State of New Jersey v. U.S. Department of Justice, No. 1:25-cv-00404-JJM-AEM, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode Island. The plaintiffs are 21 states, the District of Columbia and Pennsylvania, which sued through its governor. Attorney General Todd Blanche is a named defendant.
What the states asked for
According to the amended complaint, filed Aug. 21, the Justice Department's Office of Justice Programs put "Immigration Enforcement Conditions" in every fiscal 2025 and 2026 notice of funding opportunity and in several fiscal 2025 award notices. The complaint says the conditions require recipients to give access to people believed to be noncitizens held in state custody, to notify the Department of Homeland Security when those people are released, and to follow restrictions on sharing immigration-related information.
The states asked the court to declare the conditions unlawful, permanently block them and set them aside. They argued the conditions violate the Administrative Procedure Act, the separation of powers and the Spending Clause. The complaint says: "Nothing in any federal grant-funding statute authorizes USDOJ to impose immigration-related funding conditions on grant programs intended to support criminal law enforcement, juvenile justice, and victim services."
What the judge decided
Court Cast reported that McConnell found existing law limits the Justice Department's power to add conditions to grant programs built on funding formulas set by Congress. The ruling permanently bars the department from implementing or enforcing the conditions.
Reports differ on how far the ruling reaches. The New Jersey attorney general's office lists the Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (Byrne JAG) program among the grants covered. Court Cast reported that the ruling covers two programs, the Byrne State Crisis Intervention Program and juvenile justice grants from the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, and not Byrne JAG. Court Cast also reported that the Justice Department maintains an injunction from the first Trump term already bars it from imposing similar conditions on Byrne JAG. The states say they received about $80 million through Byrne JAG in fiscal 2025, according to Court Cast.
What the money pays for
New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport said the grants pay for officer protective equipment, drug trafficking investigations, body cameras and a program that pairs police with mental health professionals, the Jersey Vindicator reported. New Jersey was allocated about $4.2 million in Byrne grants and $2.7 million through the crisis intervention program for fiscal 2025. Connecticut received more than $6.8 million in Byrne JAG funds and $5.1 million in crisis intervention funds across fiscal 2022 to 2025, CT News Junkie reported.
"We will continue to fight the Administration's brazenly unlawful actions that put politics over public safety," Davenport said.
What happens next
The Justice Department did not immediately comment, Court Cast reported, and none of the coverage reviewed mentions an appeal or a next hearing. This is the second round of this fight. In 2025 the administration put similar conditions on more than $1.3 billion in Victims of Crime Act funding and later removed them after the states sued, according to CT News Junkie.
Sources
- Amended complaint, State of New Jersey v. U.S. Department of Justice, D.R.I. (filed Aug. 21, 2026)
- New Jersey Office of the Attorney General: Davenport, multistate coalition win major case protecting crucial law enforcement funding
- Court Cast: US judge blocks Trump administration's bid to tie state grants to immigration enforcement
- Jersey Vindicator: Federal judge blocks Trump administration from tying police grants to immigration enforcement
- CT News Junkie: CT-backed lawsuit blocks immigration conditions on public safety grants
Comments ()