The law pays tax-leak victims $1,000 per leak. Trump's Justice Department offered a Trump golf pro $500,000.

Two political appointees signed a $2.5 million offer to five plaintiffs in an IRS leak suit, ProPublica reported. More want in.

The law pays tax-leak victims $1,000 per leak. Trump's Justice Department offered a Trump golf pro $500,000.
Stock photo. Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

Federal law sets the baseline payout for a taxpayer whose return is illegally leaked at $1,000 per disclosure. Two Trump Justice Department appointees offered $500,000 apiece to five plaintiffs in a tax-leak lawsuit, including the longtime golf pro at Trump National Golf Club Hudson Valley.

ProPublica reported Nov. 19 that the five plaintiffs in Safe Harbor International LLC v. Booz Allen Hamilton, a class action in federal court in Maryland, collected $2.5 million. The case grew out of the leak by Charles Littlejohn, a Booz Allen contractor at the IRS who pleaded guilty in 2023 to disclosing tax data, including Trump's returns, to news organizations, among them ProPublica.

Who got paid

The court record lists the five plaintiffs: Safe Harbor International LLC, Alarm Concepts Inc. of Texas, Belpointe Sleepovation Investment LP of Connecticut, Cedrick Williams of Texas and Shelby Lowman of Ridgefield, Connecticut, according to an April 1, 2026 opinion by U.S. District Judge Lydia Kay Griggsby.

Two of the five have Trump ties, ProPublica reported. Lowman has worked at the Hudson Valley club for 17 years and paints Trump golf courses; Trump has autographed the paintings for club prizes. Safe Harbor investor Donald Wilson's trading firm said it put $100 million into Trump Media months after the SEC dropped a case against a crypto company he controlled. A Wilson spokesperson said he "was unaware of this lawsuit until last week."

What the law allows

Under 26 U.S.C. § 7431, a liable defendant owes "the greater of" $1,000 "for each act of unauthorized inspection or disclosure" or the plaintiff's actual damages, plus punitive damages for willful or grossly negligent leaks. The plaintiffs alleged two disclosures each, worth $2,000 apiece, ProPublica reported. More would require proof of actual harm, and the case never reached fact-finding.

The Justice Department first fought the case, arguing the government wasn't the right target for a contractor's conduct. Griggsby found the plaintiffs "plausibly allege" Littlejohn was a federal employee with "staff-like access to IRS systems," and wrote that the court "DENIES the Government Defendants' motion to dismiss."

In August, the department switched course and made an offer of judgment of $500,000 per plaintiff, signed by two political appointees: Brett Shumate, then head of the Civil Division, and Joshua Wu, deputy assistant attorney general over tax litigation. The career trial attorney didn't sign it, and IRS chief counsel lawyers weren't consulted, ProPublica reported.

Gil Rothenberg, who ran the Justice Department tax division's appellate section for 15 years, told ProPublica the deal "is not passing the smell test."

The Justice Department and IRS declined to comment on a pending case. A White House spokesperson said the department is "promoting efficient resolution of cases to avoid extraordinary liability." The record cuts against that claim: the payout is 250 times the statutory amount, and the deal did not end the case.

More claimants are lining up

Since the payout, two more people with Trump business ties have sought to join the suit: a retired accountant from the Hudson Valley club and an apparent former lifeguard at a Westchester Trump club, ProPublica reported. The plaintiffs say the class runs "in the tens or hundreds of thousands." The IRS sent leak notices to more than 400,000 individuals and businesses. If many collected $500,000, the bill could reach billions. By contrast, billionaire Ken Griffin dropped his 2022 leak suit in exchange for an IRS apology and got no money, ProPublica noted.

A pattern of payouts to Trump allies

The Safe Harbor deal is part of a pattern of the Trump Justice Department paying, or being asked to pay, Trump and his allies. For example:

  • May 19, 2025: The administration agreed to pay nearly $5 million to the family of Ashli Babbitt, who was shot and killed after breaching the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, to end a $30 million suit, CNN reported.
  • Oct. 21, 2025: Trump was seeking $230 million from the Justice Department he oversees through administrative claims over the Russia and classified-documents investigations, NBC News reported, citing The New York Times.
  • May 18, 2026: After Trump sued the IRS seeking "at least $10,000,000,000.00" over the same leak, the department settled by creating a $1.776 billion "Anti-Weaponization Fund." It dropped the fund in June after a judge blocked it and lawmakers objected, but kept provisions shielding Trump and his family from audits of past returns. On July 13, U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams found the suit collusive and sanctioned Trump's lawyers, and the Eleventh Circuit refused on Sept. 29 to pause those sanctions.

What's next

The Safe Harbor case remains open in Maryland, with no next hearing date in the records reviewed. Former IRS Commissioner John Koskinen told ProPublica the deal "opens the door to Trump himself benefiting from this settlement." As of the Sept. 29 appeals order, Williams had not ruled on a request from 35 former federal judges to reopen Trump's IRS case.

Sources