A federal judge threw out SNAP soda bans in five states. SNAP families now ask her to void bans in 18 more.

The class action, assigned Nov. 19 to Judge Amy Berman Jackson, covers more than 11 million people on SNAP plus South Carolina convenience stores.

A federal judge threw out SNAP soda bans in five states. SNAP families now ask her to void bans in 18 more.
Stock photo. Photo by Illia Bondar on Unsplash

The federal judge who threw out SNAP soda and candy bans in five states this summer will hear the challenge to bans in 18 more. On Nov. 19, the court assigned Meyer v. Rollins, a proposed class action filed the day before, to U.S. District Judge Amy Berman Jackson after the plaintiffs flagged it as related to the case she decided in June, the court docket shows.

Seventeen SNAP recipients and the South Carolina Convenience & Petroleum Marketers Association, a convenience-store trade group, filed the suit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia against Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins and USDA. It asks the court to vacate USDA's approval of food-restriction waivers in Arkansas, Florida, Hawaii, Idaho, Indiana, Kansas, Louisiana, Missouri, Montana, Nevada, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Texas, Utah, Virginia and Wyoming, and to bar USDA from approving new ones. More than 11 million people got SNAP in those states as of October, the complaint says.

Same law, same judge

A waiver lets a state strike items like soda from SNAP's federal definition of "food." The complaint calls the waivers "a uniform, nationwide initiative orchestrated by the United States Department of Agriculture ('USDA') to restrict access to, and ultimately shrink the size and efficacy of," SNAP. USDA approved every one under 7 U.S.C. § 2026(b), the complaint says. That is the same provision Jackson ruled in June covers only administrative pilot projects, not health ones. The complaint also alleges that waivers in eight states took effect before USDA published the public notice its own rules require.

"The legal and factual issues are identical to those the court has already determined," Jeffrey Shinder, founding partner at Shinder Cantor Lerner, said in a joint release with the National Center for Law and Economic Justice (NCLEJ). Katharine Deabler-Meadows, NCLEJ senior attorney, called the waivers "a backdoor method to restrict access to SNAP."

A USDA spokesperson told Agri-Pulse the department "looks forward to vigorously and swiftly defending" the approvals. The spokesperson also claimed "the left found vulnerable recipients and convenien[ce] stores to use as pawns against the Make America Healthy Again agenda." That attacks the plaintiffs' motives, not their argument: the named plaintiffs describe their own medical conditions, and the statement skips the legal question Jackson already decided. The spokesperson also said convenience stores spent money "avoiding" stocking standards the 2014 farm bill authorized. That is half-true: Congress itself blocked enforcement in a 2017 spending bill, the National Agricultural Law Center notes, and stocking rules don't bear on whether the waivers are legal.

Losing in court hasn't slowed USDA

USDA has kept launching bans and taking new requests under the same authority since its June loss. For example:

  • June 22, 2026: Jackson vacated waivers in Colorado, Iowa, Nebraska, Tennessee and West Virginia, finding section 2026(b) "does not cover projects aimed towards improving the health of SNAP recipients" (opinion). The Justice Department filed a notice of appeal to the D.C. Circuit on Aug. 20.
  • Oct. 2, 2026: USDA asked for public comment on Nebraska's new request, filed under the same provision, to ban soda and energy drinks starting Dec. 1 (USDA notice). As of Nov. 21, USDA's Nebraska page said "We are working on a response."
  • Nov. 1, 2026: Montana, North Dakota, South Carolina and Virginia began their bans, as WorkersRights.News reported.

Who pays at the register

The waivers allow no exceptions for medical or job needs, the complaint says. Nichole Martin, a part-time hospice caregiver in Tyler, Texas, travels to patients' homes in the heat. She can no longer use SNAP for the Gatorade and Powerade she relies on during long workdays. Christy Trent of Vinton, Virginia, can't work because of dizziness and fainting, and a soda is the only thing that stops a spell, according to the complaint.

Store workers enforce the rules. When a shopper picks a restricted item, "it falls to a cashier to explain that the product cannot be purchased," the complaint says. One member chain told USDA that compliance "effectively adds a full-time position." The same chain sorted about 12,700 product codes before South Carolina's ban began. The complaint alleges that USDA's December 2025 guidance uses secret shoppers and threatens to drop a store from SNAP after a second violation. South Carolina retailers face that enforcement starting Jan. 29, 2027.

What's next

No hearing has been set. As of the docket's last entry on Nov. 19, no motion for a preliminary injunction had been filed. Meanwhile, bans are scheduled to start in Wyoming on Feb. 1, Kansas and Missouri on Feb. 15, and Hawaii and Ohio on April 1, 2027, according to USDA's waiver list. Separately, USDA is proposing a rule that would cut 6.3 million people from SNAP. If you use SNAP in a waiver state, check your state agency's list of restricted items before you shop.

Sources