Ohio Supreme Court orders some ballots kept sealed in a state House race separated by 33 votes
A GOP candidate wants ballots from voters who moved between counties tossed. Lucas County says it already counted them.
The Ohio Supreme Court on Thursday ordered the Lucas County Board of Elections to keep certain provisional ballots "sealed, unopened, and uncounted until the court decides this action," granting part of an emergency request from Republican Ohio House candidate Edward Schimmel.
Schimmel, the mayor of Northwood, leads Democrat David Fournier by 33 votes in Ohio House District 44, Democracy Docket reported. The ballots at issue were cast at neighborhood polling places by voters who moved to Lucas County from another Ohio county without updating their registration.
The case
In State ex rel. Schimmel v. Lucas County Board of Elections (No. 2026-1574), filed Nov. 16, Schimmel asks the court to order the board to find those ballots ineligible and "to leave those ballot envelopes unopened and uncounted, record their rejection, and preserve them." His complaint argues state law sends county-to-county movers to the board office, not their polling place, and that Secretary of State Frank LaRose's directive allowing polling-place voting conflicts with that law.
Chief Justice Sharon Kennedy signed the one-page order. It covers those envelopes only "to the extent" they "remain sealed and unopened."
That limit may matter. In its answer, the board says it approved about 2,400 provisional ballots on Nov. 16, opened the envelopes and finished counting them Nov. 17. It calls the case moot and says Schimmel waited too long. How many ballots, if any, the order still covers isn't known.
The other side
Fournier has asked to join the case and have it dismissed. His lawyers at Elias Law Group wrote in a proposed motion that "Schimmel seeks to change the rules of the game after it has already been played." Treating Lucas County voters differently from similar voters in other counties would violate equal protection, they argue.
The ACLU of Ohio and League of Women Voters of Ohio filed a brief noting that officials in other counties "have already counted similar votes during this election cycle," WTOL reported.
WR.N covered the first round of this fight on Thursday: Republicans ask Ohio Supreme Court to toss ballots in a House race decided by under 40 votes.
What's next
The court hasn't set a decision date. WTOL reported that the county's canvass must be certified by Tuesday.
Sources
- Supreme Court of Ohio, order in State ex rel. Schimmel v. Lucas County Board of Elections, No. 2026-1574 (Nov. 19, 2026) (copy hosted by Democracy Docket)
- Schimmel's verified complaint (Nov. 16, 2026)
- Lucas County Board of Elections, answer (Nov. 18, 2026)
- David Fournier, proposed motion to dismiss (Nov. 18, 2026)
- Democracy Docket: Ohio Supreme Court orders some ballots to remain uncounted following GOP challenge
- WTOL (via Yahoo News): Ohio Supreme Court orders some uncounted provisional ballots to remain sealed
- WTOL (via Yahoo News): Lucas County Board of Elections approves thousands of provisional ballots
Comments ()