> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.workersrights.news/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Wisconsin Supreme Court will hear unions' Act 10 challenge. Bargaining rights for most public workers are at stake.
- URL: https://www.workersrights.news/wisconsin-supreme-court-act-10-review/
- Published: 2026-11-12T20:54:29.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-12T20:54:29.000Z
- Description: The court voted 5-1 to review the 2011 law; the unions' brief is due Dec. 11, and Act 10 stays in force meanwhile.
- Author: WorkersRights.News Team
- Tags: Legal News, Politics

The Wisconsin Supreme Court agreed Wednesday, Nov. 11, to decide whether Act 10, the 2011 law that took most bargaining rights away from teachers and other public workers, violates the state constitution. The order, in *Abbotsford Education Association v. Wisconsin Employment Relations Commission* (No. 2024AP2429), grants the unions' petition for review. Justice Annette Kingsland Ziegler dissented, and Justice Brian Hagedorn did not take part.

Act 10 stays in force while the case moves forward, and the unsigned order gives no reasons, [WPR reported](https://www.wpr.org/news/wisconsin-supreme-court-act-10-lawsuit?ref=workersrights.news).

### What the court ordered

The [order](https://content.govdelivery.com/attachments/WICOURTS/2026/11/11/file%5Fattachments/3854500/24AP2429%20%20Abbotsford%20v%20WERC%20-%20PRE%20Grant%20Order.pdf?ref=workersrights.news) says "the petition for review is granted" and that the unions "may not raise or argue issues not set forth in the petition for review unless otherwise ordered by the court." The unions' brief is due within 30 days, which puts it at Dec. 11\. The state, the Republican-led Legislature and intervenor Kristi Koschkee, a teacher, then have 20 days to respond, and the unions get 10 days to reply. No date for oral argument has been set.

Hagedorn was chief legal counsel to Gov. Scott Walker when Act 10 was written and [withdrew from the case last year](https://fox11online.com/news/state/supreme-court-case-abbotsford-education-association-v-wisconsin-employment-relations-commission-challenging-act-10-collective-bargaining-union-law-public-sector-madison-protests-capitol-scowis?ref=workersrights.news), the Associated Press reported. Ziegler retires next July, WPR reported.

### Who kept rights, and who lost them

Act 10 split public workers into two classes. Police officers, firefighters and some other "public safety" workers kept full rights. Everyone else became a "general employee" who can bargain only over base pay, with raises capped at inflation, and whose union must win a vote every year from at least 51% of all workers in the unit, not 51% of those who vote. It also ended payroll dues deduction and made workers pay more for health insurance and pensions, the AP reported.

Teacher associations, AFSCME locals, SEIU Wisconsin, an AFT local and Teamsters Local 695 sued in 2023\. They argue the line violates equal protection (the state constitution's promise of equal treatment absent a rational reason), since Capitol Police, prison officers and conservation wardens landed in the "general" group. In December 2024, Dane County Circuit Judge Jacob Frost agreed, writing that he could find "no rational basis for excluding some police and fire employees from the public safety group while including all others and motor vehicle inspectors," as [the appeals court quoted him](https://www.wicourts.gov/ca/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=1152252&ref=workersrights.news).

On July 29, a 2-1 panel of the District II Court of Appeals reversed. "This is not a close case," the unsigned majority wrote, holding that lawmakers could have had a reason for each line they drew. Presiding Judge Neubauer dissented, writing that the challenged provisions "are unconstitutional." The unions now ask the justices to overturn it.

### Fifteen years of Act 10

Wisconsin's public-sector union membership rate fell from 46.6% in 2010 to 18.5% in 2025, [Wisconsin Watch reported](https://wisconsinwatch.org/2026/10/wisconsin-act-10-union-law-reckoning-public-employee-collective-bargaining-supreme-court-election/?ref=workersrights.news), citing the Center for Economic and Policy Research. Before Act 10, employers paid more than 99% of contributions to the Wisconsin Retirement System; by 2020 they paid about half. The Wisconsin Policy Forum estimated that shift saved governments nearly $5.2 billion from 2011 to 2017.

In Racine, 1,368 teachers and 158 school maintenance workers still go through the yearly union vote. "We have seen over time the very real impacts of eroded collective bargaining rights on teachers in the classroom," state Rep. Angelina Cruz, D-Racine, a former leader of the Racine teachers union, told Racine County Eye.

### Who's for it, who's against it

Lucas Vebber, deputy counsel at the conservative Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty, which represents Koschkee, [said](https://will-law.org/wisconsin-supreme-court-to-hear-act-10-appeal-will-reacts?ref=workersrights.news) Act 10 "meets every constitutional requirement" and "We stand ready to make that case once again." WILL claims repeal would cost local governments and schools more than $2 billion a year. Two labor-law professors filed a brief disputing such cost claims, [according to Law Forward](https://www.lawforward.org/abbotsford-v-wi-employment-relations/?ref=workersrights.news), which represents the unions.

Democrats take control of both legislative chambers and the governor's office in January for the first time since Act 10 passed. Gov.-elect David Crowley said in a [July statement](https://urbanmilwaukee.com/pressrelease/county-executive-david-crowley-statement-on-act-10-appeals-court-decision/?ref=workersrights.news), "As governor, I will repeal Act 10 in full." "Collective bargaining works," Senate Democratic Leader Dianne Hesselbein told Wisconsin Watch.

Restoring public-sector union rights by statute has precedent in the Midwest. In March 2023, after Democrats won full control of Michigan's government, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer [signed a repeal](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/michigan-becomes-1st-state-in-decades-to-repeal-right-to-work-law?ref=workersrights.news) of the state's 2012 right-to-work law, the first such repeal by any state in 58 years.

### What it means for public workers

For now, nothing changes for teachers, nurses, librarians, sanitation crews and other general employees: their unions still face yearly recertification votes and can bargain only over base pay. If the unions win, the limits Frost struck down would fall, and any new pay or benefit terms would still have to be won at the bargaining table. Next up are the unions' brief on Dec. 11 and the court's choice of an argument date.

### Sources

- [Order granting petition for review, Abbotsford Education Association v. WERC, No. 2024AP2429 (Nov. 11, 2026)](https://content.govdelivery.com/attachments/WICOURTS/2026/11/11/file%5Fattachments/3854500/24AP2429%20%20Abbotsford%20v%20WERC%20-%20PRE%20Grant%20Order.pdf?ref=workersrights.news), Wisconsin Supreme Court
- [Abbotsford Education Association v. WERC, No. 2024AP2429, decision (July 29, 2026)](https://www.wicourts.gov/ca/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=1152252&ref=workersrights.news), Wisconsin Court of Appeals, District II
- [Wisconsin Supreme Court will hear Act 10 lawsuit](https://www.wpr.org/news/wisconsin-supreme-court-act-10-lawsuit?ref=workersrights.news), WPR
- [Wisconsin Supreme Court to hear case challenging Act 10](https://fox11online.com/news/state/supreme-court-case-abbotsford-education-association-v-wisconsin-employment-relations-commission-challenging-act-10-collective-bargaining-union-law-public-sector-madison-protests-capitol-scowis?ref=workersrights.news), WLUK/Associated Press
- [Wisconsin Supreme Court takes Act 10 case: Racine impact](https://racinecountyeye.com/2026/11/11/wisconsin-supreme-court-act-10-racine-public-workers/?ref=workersrights.news), Racine County Eye
- [Wisconsin's controversial anti-union law faces a reckoning this fall](https://wisconsinwatch.org/2026/10/wisconsin-act-10-union-law-reckoning-public-employee-collective-bargaining-supreme-court-election/?ref=workersrights.news), Wisconsin Watch
- [Wisconsin Supreme Court to Hear Act 10 Appeal, WILL Reacts](https://will-law.org/wisconsin-supreme-court-to-hear-act-10-appeal-will-reacts?ref=workersrights.news), Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty
- [Abbotsford et al v. WI Employment Relations Commission et al (case page)](https://www.lawforward.org/abbotsford-v-wi-employment-relations/?ref=workersrights.news), Law Forward
- [County Executive David Crowley Statement on Act 10 Appeals Court Decision](https://urbanmilwaukee.com/pressrelease/county-executive-david-crowley-statement-on-act-10-appeals-court-decision/?ref=workersrights.news), Urban Milwaukee (press release)
- [Michigan becomes 1st state in decades to repeal 'right-to-work' law](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/michigan-becomes-1st-state-in-decades-to-repeal-right-to-work-law?ref=workersrights.news), PBS NewsHour